If any pop album of 2007 seemed like a sure thing it was Kelly Clarkson's third record, My December. Kelly definitively shook off the stigma of American Idol with her second album Breakaway and, in particular, its smash hit “Since U Been Gone,” an anthem so irresistible it was inescapable, beloved by teenage girls and hipsters alike (it even inspired a pretty good cover from oak-hearted indie hero, Ted Leo). Kelly had it all: hits and some burgeoning cred, so it seemed that there was no way to screw up the next album, the one that would cement her as a rock & roll queen. Turns out, that was a large part of the problem: Clarkson wanted to be a rocker, while her benefactor, the legendary record mogul Clive Davis, wanted her to stick as a pop star, setting the stage for a massive battle that spilled over into the tabloids and blogs. Kelly wrote and recorded her album as a rock record - getting much mileage out of PR shots of her mugging with Minuteman Mike Watt, which also helped strengthen her legitimacy as a rocker (even though all the accompanying articles suggested she didn't really know Firehose from Firehouse but, to be fair, how many people do in 2007?) - but when it came time to release it, Davis balked, allegedly claiming there were no hit singles on the record at a label conference (then playing a few cuts as proof) and then taking several not-so-veiled swipes at her during the 2007 American Idol finale. Clarkson held her ground, insisting that My December come out the way she intended, firing her management team after the fight with Davis (afterward, her first headlining arena tour was cancelled, only increasing her bad press), but eventually getting the album in the stores in late June 2007.
My December proves that both camps were correct: Davis is correct that there are no big crossover hits here, yet it's also true that this is an artistic move that Clarkson needed to make. If left up to Davis, she would simply be another vocalist singing professional product - the kind of singer AmIdol was designed to find. But Clarkson is young and moderately hip - at least hip enough to know that the she wants to sound fresher, younger than American Idol, so she needed to shake loose the shackles of the pop machine. That, combined with real life heartbreak (her guy left her, a situation she doesn't shy away from on the album's lyrics), gave her the fuel to turn her third album into an statement of purpose. Unfortunately, what she wants to be is Evanescence - gothic and operatic, filled with roiling emotions but few hooks. She tempers this with a few rock moves learned from Pink, but the end result is that My December is more sound than song, which is nevertheless kind of modern: although this sound is starting to show its age as Hot Topic stores are starting to shutter, it nevertheless is a very contemporary sound and suits those girls that are growing up with Kelly, following her from Idol, through college, into an uneasy adulthood. It's a soundtrack to their lives, and perhaps even more so than before since this awkward record is the sound of Kelly negotiating adulthood, unafraid of making mistakes. Even if it's not heavy on strong songs, it ironically is the most sonically unified record Kelly has made to date: it follows through on Clarkson's vision of being a modern rocker, cutting away all the stultifying adult contemporary and replacing them with emotional acoustic ballads, but relying on surging rockers. It's what Kelly wanted to do, so on that level it's a success, and one that listeners who share her viewpoint (and quite likely her age) will respond to but for everybody else, My December is a disappointment. To those like Davis, who always viewed her as nothing more than a singer -- expecting Kelly to be a pop version of Carrie Underwood and singing whatever pretty song put in front of her -- it's a crushing disappointment because it is deliberately not a pop record. Not that it's alienating, per se - as Kelly said prior to it's release, “it's not Metallica,” it's doesn't push away the listeners - but there are no hooks, nothing to suck in the many adults that liked Clarkson's first two records. And that's not limited to the middle-Americans that turned her into the first Amerian Idol, either: there aren't hooks for the hipsters or pop junkies that loved “Since U Been Gone” (or even “Breakaway” and “Miss Independent”), the kind of listener that have been craving Kelly Clarkson to be a cool rock chick, since she has the pipes and spunkiness to be everybody's favorite girl next door rocker. But that's not what Kelly wants to be - she wants to be Amy Lee or Pink, turning inward and writing from the heart, chronicling a turbulent time in her life. A few times, she comes up aces - whether it's the bubbly electronics of “One Minute” that give this album some much needed spark, or the ruminative acoustic “Irvine” - but these are hard-won modest triumphs surrounding by over-reaching confessions that play like clichés. And that's the conundrum of Kelly Clarkson - she's a terrific singer and a very likeable star, but she achieved her fame by just wanting to be a singer, and after she achieved fame, she wanted to be an artist by going against the very music that earned her an audience. She may retain her hardcore, but it's unlikely that the mass audience will follow here since she's not making music for the masses here. Nevertheless, as Simon Cowell so sagely argued, by winning Idol and turning into a star in her own right, she's earned the right to follow her gut, no matter where it leads, so she's entitled to a difficult third album like My December. The real question now is where does this road lead her.